- The attorney wanted maintenance, contempt and arrest-related orders suspended while he challenged whether he was the child’s biological father.
- The High Court in Polokwane found that the existing maintenance order remained binding and that the attorney had not established grounds for suspending it.
- Judge Diamond dismissed the application and ordered the attorney to pay the mother’s legal costs on an attorney-and-client scale.
A practising attorney has been ordered to pay his former partner’s legal costs on a punitive scale after failing to convince the High Court in Polokwane to stop the enforcement of maintenance and contempt orders.
This application followed years of court battles over maintenance payments, contempt proceedings, a criminal case, and a separate dispute over who the father is of a child born in August 2023.
The dispute started on 19 December 2023, when Judge TC Tshidada made a maintenance order under Rule 43. The attorney was told to pay R12,000 a month for the mother and R9,000 a month for the child, plus R150,000 towards the mother’s legal costs in the ongoing divorce case.
He paid maintenance from January to July 2024 before he stopped. Judge Tshidada later found him in contempt and ordered him to pay the outstanding amount. Acting Judge TE Matumba also found him in contempt on 6 September 2024 and authorised his imprisonment for 60 days.
Although Judge Matumba later tried to change that order, the mother appealed. On 16 March 2026, a Full Court put things back to how they were before. The Supreme Court of Appeal turned down the attorney’s application for special leave to appeal on 19 June 2026, so the September 2024 contempt order stayed in place.
The attorney also faced criminal charges for not following the maintenance order. He was convicted in the Malamulele Magistrate’s Court in January 2025 under section 31 of the Maintenance Act and received a suspended sentence. Later, he was prosecuted again after he missed a court appearance, so a warrant was issued for his arrest.
In his latest application, the attorney wanted to put the maintenance and contempt orders on hold, stop them from being enforced, and prevent the police from arresting him. He said he had a vasectomy in 2010, and tests showed he was infertile, so he could not have fathered the child. He also said the mother refused to cooperate with an earlier order for DNA testing.
The paternity issue is also the subject of a separate appeal. On 17 October 2025, an order was granted requiring the attorney, the mother, and the child to undergo DNA testing. The mother appealed against that order, and the Supreme Court of Appeal granted her leave to appeal to a Full Court on 18 March 2026. The appeal is set down for hearing on 20 November 2026.
The attorney insisted he was not asking the court to permanently set aside the existing orders. He said, “I do not seek, by means of the present urgent application, to invite this Honourable Court finally to rescind or set aside the orders previously granted by Judge Tshidada or Judge Matumba.”
The mother opposed the application. She said the orders were still valid, the attorney had not paid maintenance for a long time, and the case was not really urgent. She said the amount still owed was R378,000.
Why the application failed
Acting Judge G Diamond said the maintenance order would stay in place until a court changed it or set it aside. The attorney had already been told before that the right way to deal with this was to apply under Rule 43(6) or finalise the divorce case.
An earlier judgment said, “There is no legal basis on which this court can suspend the operation of the Rule 43 order.” The judge said the attorney’s Rule 43(6) application was already pending in Thohoyandou, and the paternity dispute was also before the Children’s Court and the Full Court.
The judge also found that an earlier order by Acting Judge M Chidi had only put the October 2025 arrest warrant on hold, pending an inquiry by the magistrate. It did not set the warrant aside. The J50 warrant issued in July 2026 was a separate matter, and the attorney had not shown that it was unlawful.
The magistrates’ court was the right place to handle the attorney’s failure to appear, the question of bail or warning, and whether the maintenance prosecution had merit. The magistrate and prosecutors involved had not been included in this application.
Judge Diamond also found that the urgency was mostly self-created. The attorney knew about the earlier arrest warrant, but had not tried the options available in the magistrates’ court. The judge looked at the merits, even though there were doubts about urgency, but decided the attorney had not made out a case for the relief he wanted.
The judgment did not decide whether the attorney was the child’s biological father, whether there was a valid customary marriage, or whether he was guilty under the Maintenance Act. These issues will still have to be decided in the right cases.
Punitive costs
The judge found that the application repeated issues already looked at by other courts, or that were still pending elsewhere. He did not find that the attorney acted with a hidden motive, but said that bringing urgent applications again and again for the same relief was very close to abusing the court process.
Judge Diamond also criticised the attorney for saying that Judge Chidi’s order had set aside the arrest warrant, and for not telling the court about an earlier failed urgent application before Acting Judge M. Bresler. The judge said a practising attorney is expected to be especially honest with the court.
These things, along with the self-created urgency, meant a punitive costs order was justified. The court dismissed the application and ordered the attorney to pay the mother’s legal costs on an attorney-and-client scale, including the costs of one counsel to be taxed on Scale B.
Get your news on the go. Click here to follow the Conviction WhatsApp channel.

